Really take this in:

A Hamas official quoted by the International Crisis Group, or ICG, said the move violated the "reasonable rules of the game: that when Palestinian projectiles hit open space ... Israel aims at open space in response."

  • Comment Filters
Contributor Comments
Member Comments
Comment Popularity

Comments :

Blake
Joined
Oct '10
Blake

Ah, yes. This is why a soldier on a battlefield who feels an enemy's bullet whiz by his ear is morally obliged to fire his next round into the dirt. It's only fair. Good manners and all.

Kennedy Smith
Joined
May '10
Kennedy Smith

In that case, much bloodshed could be averted if they turned their creativity toward making rude gestures.

Claire Berlinski, Ed.

I don't even know where to start, really.

flownover
Joined
Aug '10
flownover

Overwhelming professionalism is no excuse for success.

I suppose David was too tall for Goliath anyway ?

Brian Watt
Joined
Jun '10
Brian Watt

Ah...it's a game. Well, that explains everything. Where are my tennis whites and racket? I say chaps, anyone for tennis? I say, you there with the funny looking vest...

Daniel Frank
Joined
May '10
Daniel Frank

The Harrison Bergeron rules of war.

Aaron Miller
Joined
May '10
Aaron Miller

The IDF's water balloon funding might not be cut afterall.


Joined
Jan '11
Anon

What if the Israelis fire first?  Do the miss-for-miss rules still apply?

Brian Watt
Joined
Jun '10
Brian Watt
SMatthewStolte
Joined
Feb '11
SMatthewStolte

Actually, it seems like it should be: if A aims at B and hits open space, then B should aim at open space and hit A.

(I hate to make light of such an awful situation, but how else do you make it through the day?)

tabula rasa
Joined
Jun '10
tabula rasa

I suggest we move this to a virtual platform.  Let the best Israeli kid and the best Gazan kid engage in a game of Mortal Combat and avoid the whole "empty space" thing.

I'll put my money on the Israeli kid. 

Israel Pickholtz
Joined
Feb '11
Israel P.

The UN and others have been saying this for years.  It's what they mean when they say "disproportionate."

Ajax Telamônios
Joined
Jan '11
Ajax Telamônios
Israel P.: The UN and others have been saying this for years.  It's what they mean when they say "disproportionate."  

Disproportionate = hitting what you're aiming for.

Sisyphus
Joined
Jul '10
Sisyphus

Don't start nuttin', won't be nuttin'.

flownover
Joined
Aug '10
flownover

Sir Robin of Gaza I presume ? 

Jerry Broaddus
Joined
Dec '10
Jerry Broaddus
Daniel Frank: The Harrison Bergeron rules of war. · Mar 30 at 8:23am

Exactly.


Joined
Dec '10
Nickolas

Sounds like something I might see in a Looney Tunes cartoon.

According to Hamas' rules of self-defense, I cannot shoot any assailants that are shooting at my family until they manage to hit one of them. Until then I can only return fire if I deliberately miss.

Edited on Mar 30, 2011 at 11:35am
Stuart Creque
Joined
Dec '10
Stuart Creque

Proportionality in a war of survival is profoundly immoral. Proportionality means that there's an acceptable, comfortable level of death and terror that the two sides can agree upon. Of course the Europeans want proportionality between Hamas and Israel, because they don't care if some Jews and Arabs die every month. But Israel ought to take the moral position that massive disproportionality will convince Hamas to cease its military activity altogether. By the way, the deaths in Itamar and Jerusalem count as grounds for deadly retaliation against Gazan terror groups and their Hamas protectors.

Stuart Creque
Joined
Dec '10
Stuart Creque

One of the reasons the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy advises travelers to keep a towel with them at all times is for protection against one of the most fearsome creatures in the galaxy, the ravenous Bugblatter Beast of Traal. Though it will attack and kill you on sight, the Bugblatter Beast is incredibly stupid. If you can't see it, it assumes that it can't see you... so your only defense is to cover your head with your towel, at which point the Beast will realize you can't see it and will leave you alone. For some reason, that came to mind.

flownover
Joined
Aug '10
flownover
Stuart Creque: One of the reasons the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy advises travelers to keep a towel with them at all times is for protection against one of the most fearsome creatures in the galaxy, the ravenous Bugblatter Beast of Traal. Though it will attack and kill you on sight, the Bugblatter Beast is incredibly stupid. If you can't see it, it assumes that it can't see you... so your only defense is to cover your head with your towel, at which point the Beast will realize you can't see it and will leave you alone. For some reason, that came to mind. · Mar 30 at 12:29pm

Thanks, any chance your child is named Trillian ?

putty putty putty putty putty putty putty 

putty 

putty putty


Would you like to comment on this Conversation?

Become a Member for $3.67 a month.

Join the Conversation
Already a member? Sign In
Loading

Welcome Visitor

Already a Member?
Please Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Join Ricochet today!

Already a Member? Sign In