Over at Reason, Nick Gillespie has a mostly insightful and important rumination on the very American people who descended on Washington, D.C. for Glenn Beck's Restoring Honor Rally. His take on the role of religion, however, is a little off. Okay, maybe a lot off.

Gillespie notes that Beck "is channeling a very strong tradition in American with regards to religion and the public square." He describes the objective of that tradition as "'embracing' God and putting him back in the center of our lives, both private and public." But Gillespie thinks that any "anxiety" about "turning God [...] out of the public square" is misplaced, because "politicians are far more publicly pious than they used to be." He admits "that may be less important than the feeling" -- but can't identify any rational source for that feeling. This is a mistake.

But the truth is hiding in plain sight, between the lines of Gillespie's otherwise clear-eyed synopsis. ...

Show more
George Savage
River: Our hubris is laughable, except the real-world consequences of such conceit are very serious.
Our minds are miraculous, and have allowed us to do remarkable things; but the truth is this, a common insect is a miracle of engineering we may never duplicate, much less create. Much of our seeming understanding is illusory. We name things and believe we've explained them.
"Oh, yes, lightning. That's just electricity."
"The sun? That's fusion."
"The brain's thoughts are just an electro-chemical reaction."· Sep 4 at 1:52pm

For an example of how right you are, ask someone, as generally only a child can, a nested series of whys. You can start with why the sun is hot, objects fall or any other question and within a few replies even the most well-informed says, "that's just the way it is."

The more I learn the more convinced I am of how little I really know.

George Savage
Andrew Alain: And it should be noted that the string theory, the theory that underpins the mutliverse concept, has not been experimentally verified. To my knowledge no one has even used string theory to make a testable prediction. So we have unobservable universes predicted by an untested theory. · Sep 4 at 11:50am Edited on Sep 04 at 01:42 pm

That's my understanding, too: No experimental validation. Plausibility exists, in a mathematical sense, from time to time. My friend the experimentalist takes great delight in punching holes in this framework with another observation in our universe that forces the theorists back to the mathematical equivalent of creative writing class.

Unfortunately for the state of popular culture, a good brain is all you need for theory, while the disqualifying experiments take years and gobs of money to conduct, competing for space at one of a very few high-energy labs around the world. So theoreticians playing at theology get most of the press most of the time.

At the Washington Examiner, Mark Tapscott reports that "one of President Obama's earliest policy moves on the energy and environment front has been shut down by a federal judge."

U.S. District Judge Dee Benson ruled Thursday that Ken Salazar, Obama's Secretary of the Interior, exceeded his lawful authority in March 2009 when he suspended 77 oil and gas leases on western federal lands that had been awarded to high bidders. [...] "'the secretary exceeded his statutory authority by withdrawing leases after determining which parcels were to be leased and after holding a competitive lease during which the BLM named the plaintiffs high responsible bidders," said Benson' [...].

This case is more important as a political precedent than as a legal one, for it indicates that at least one judge has decided to enforce the letter of the law in case that involves oil and gas leases on federal lands. The issue here is of massive importance because the United States owns huge chunks of western lands over which it has well-nigh complete discretion to lease, or not to lease (to paraphrase Hamlet) these lands. ...

Show more

Our extra-special star Guest Contributor Harry Shearer had to wish us a fond adieu a bit ahead of schedule, but that won't stop us from looking back on his wit and wisdom, as we are wont to do, today -- the day before our next Guest Contributor makes his debut.

So reckon once again with the strange spectacle of the 5th anniversary coverage of Katrina... revisit the uncanny way the media tells itself -- and you -- what it wants to hear... and thrill to the speech of a President just in from planet Zarg.

All told, a very fine show indeed, Mr. Shearer. Thanks a million for dropping in. Here's a cheer for your docu, and a tip of the hat to you!

Here at Ricochet, we’ve been paying close attention to the race in Michigan’s 15th congressional district, where Dr. Rob Steele is waging a brave campaign against Democratic Congressman John Dingell. Dingell has served in the House since 1955. John Dingell has been causing trouble in Washington, in other words, for four years longer than Fidel Castro has been causing trouble in Havana.

The Steele campaign just conducted a new poll. The results? Remarkably good.

  • Although Dingell leads by nine points, Steele wins among Independents
  • Among voters who have heard of Dr. Steele--still only 39 percent of the district--Dr. Steele leads by ten points
  • When voters learn that Dr. Steele is a first-time candidate whose top priority will be to stop the out-of-control spending in Washington, he moves into a five point overall lead

You don’t have be Karl Rove or James Carville to see what this means. To win, Dr. Steele needs to do only one thing: get his message out.

To help, click here.

Adam Freedman

George, thanks for highlighting this. I'll take Hawking and his colleagues a lot more seriously the minute they can build a perpetual motion machine, or create a planet ex nihilo, or do any of the other things that they contend are perfectly consistent with scientific laws.

And then, as MFR says, I'd love to hear them prove why God did not create the multiverse.

George Savage

We all believe in something. You can't bemoan religious primitives for believing what cannot be experimentally validated while simultaneously affirming atheism -- the WSJ headline reads "Why God Did Not Create the Universe" -- on the basis of a theory that is impossible to test.

I suppose there could be a multiverse. Why can't there also be a God? Maybe He arose by chance, too. Would he be in one corner of the multiverse or the whole danged thing?

I walked past the news agent at the airport in San Francisco last night and nearly dropped my coffee on the ground when I saw the cover of Time. Blue background, Star of David fashioned out of daisies on the cover, and the headline, in the center: "Why Israel Doesn't Care About Peace." No sub-headline.

The article itself is by Karl Vick, whom I know vaguely--he was in my introductory Turkish class about five years ago--and it's actually well-written and well-observed. He makes some good points. Judith would agree with some of them, I think. But I dare say few people are going to buy the magazine and read the article or think through the points he's making or, particularly, read through to the last paragraphs, which reveal that his slant is ironic and that of course Israelis are desperate for peace--every last one of them has a kid who is either in the army or going to be soon!--but despairing of the prospect and doing the best they can to get on with things anyway, because that's the only way they can get through their days without going mad. ...

Show more

Politico reports on the latest Dem tactic to throw off a heavy whiff of desperation:

The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee’s attorneys sent Simon & Schuster a letter Thursday, hinting that the publisher may have violated several campaign finance laws that prohibit in-kind contributions by corporations by posting on its website a promotional video for a book penned by three top House Republicans.

At issue: the publishing house’s promotion of “Young Guns: A New Generation of Conservative Leaders” by Reps. Eric Cantor of Virginia, Kevin McCarthy of California and Paul Ryan of Wisconsin. The DCCC’s attorneys at Perkins Coie sent the New York-based publisher a letter saying it’s improper for a corporation to host a video on its website that directs viewers to a website that solicits contributions for Republican candidates for Congress.

... Show more

Cosmologist Steven Hawking and physicist Leonard Mlodinow publish an excerpt from their upcoming atheist apologetic “The Grand Design” in today’s Wall Street Journal.

Ignorance of nature's ways led people in ancient times to postulate many myths in an effort to make sense of their world. But eventually, people turned to philosophy, that is, to the use of reason—with a good dose of intuition—to decipher their universe. Today we use reason, mathematics and experimental test—in other words, modern science.

So, using “reason, mathematics and experimental test” we get all the benefits of modern life, including proof that the order we see around us arose spontaneously due to random chance. A problem with this argument, highlighted in recent years by sophisticated computer simulations, is that our universe seems custom-tuned for our existence, making chance evolution highly improbable. The slightest variation of one of many fundamental physical laws would make impossible, in Douglas Adams’ words, “life, the universe and everything." But there’s no need to consider agnosticism. Our intrepid cosmologists ride to the rescue:

That is not the answer of modern science. ...

Show more
Claire Berlinski

I have (American) friends who have migrated to the Gulf for the lavish, tax-free salaries. They're actually very happy. I've considered it myself, and ruled it out only on the grounds that if I'm moving anywhere, it's got to be further from Iran, not closer.

It's very hard to argue with salaries like that. Usually people think, "Oh, I'll do it for three years and save a bit, then I'll come back," but people I know have stayed for much longer. Apparently, it's quite addictive to earn tons and tons and tons of money to do jobs that are poorly-paid in the US. Who would have guessed.

John Taylor

Replying to Aaron Miller’s question, Friedman favored rules over discretion in part because rules bring greater predictability and less uncertainty which is good for investment and job-creation. But he also found that attempts by the Fed to “fine tune” usually made things worse, causing booms and busts.

Duane Oyen wonders whether monetary policy was too tight in 2008. I would say that monetary policy was too erratic in this period, especially starting in August 2007 when the crisis flared up, and that this helped bring on the panic in the fall of 2008. The Fed introduced new many lending facilities and opened its balance sheet to bail out the creditors of Bear Stearns, but then closed it to Lehman, then opened it again to AIG and then closed it again without any clear strategy.

Edited on Sep 04 at 10:01 am
Dave Carter

Ursula, you’re right,… you don’t want to go to Doha. I spent a bit of time there in the mid-90’s. The heat was unbelievable. When I was there, they imported a huge segment of their labor from the Philippines, and I gathered from talking to them that their treatment was at times questionable. They were transported each day to and from a compound that housed foreign nationals. There were some decent department stores and malls in Doha, all staffed by foreign national employees. The one bright spot was a wonderful coffee house that featured hookahs, and it was situated right at the approach end of the runway at Doha International Airport. We would sit there in the evening, with a cup of Turkish coffee, a German pastry of some sort, and a honey flavored hookah, watching the 747’s come in for a landing right over our heads. The next day, the heat would soar beyond all reason, and we remembered we were in the mid east and within SCUD range of a lot of ugly players. As for sports…well,..there’s camel racing.

Adam Freedman

Ursula: no more wine? Really? Given the well documented health benefits, I fear you're taking a big risk. Unfortunately, I'm not sure that Qatar has any reputable wine merchants.

Adam Freedman
Cas Balicki: Is it too late to order a copy of the recently passed health care bill. ...

And don't forget any spare copies of the Constitution. After all, nobody's using that for its original purpose.

The candidate was outraged - just outraged - at the country's sorry fiscal state. "We have managed to acquire $13 trillion of debt on our balance sheet," he fumed to a roomful of voters. "In my view, we have nothing to show for it." And that was a Democrat, Sen. Michael Bennet of Colorado, who voted "yes" on the stimulus, the health-care overhaul, increased education funding and other costly bills Congress approved under his party's control. Faced with a potential wipeout in November's midterm elections, candidates such as Bennet are embracing budget cuts with the enthusiasm of Reagan Republicans.

Paul Hodes, the Democratic Senate candidate in New Hampshire, recently proposed $3 billion in spending cuts that would slice airport, railroad and housing funds. Elected to the House four years ago as an anti-war progressive, Hodes lamented that "for too long, both parties have willfully spent with no regard for our nation's debt."

The new push for austerity could prove too little, too late for Democrats, who fear losing their majorities in both chambers of Congress. ...

Show more

Like a lot of Americans, I’m spending more and more time on job-search sites. I’m really, really hoping I don’t have to go back to work, but it’s sort of looking that I’ll have to. We’ve already cut down our grocery list to the barest essentials (no more US Magazine or wine), and I’m giving up my beloved 2% Greek yogurt for 0% Greek yogurt because, for some reason, only the 0% kind is sold at Costco. My husband is dropping his cell phone line. We’re probably going to get rid of our cable TV.

Even with these cuts, I still may have to return to work. So, I’ve been hitting JournalismJobs.com a couple of times a day. The chances of finding a part-time job, near our house Connecticut, which has me only working the evening and weekend hours when my husband is home, and which suits my unique (limited) skills are probably slim.

But lookee here! This morning, I see something I’m perfectly qualified for. It’s for a people person who is interested in promoting sports. That’s got “me” all over it. Wait, what’s this? ...

Show more
Dave Carter
Dan Hanson: Keynes' models are based on simplified models that treat production, labor, and capital as aggregates. To me, that's the big flaw. You can't just treat the production of a nation as a single variable.

Dan, that really sums it up, doesn't it? By ignoring the millions of variables, decisions, and inclinations of the market and treating them as an aggregate, the government substitutes it's judgement for that of the people on the premise that government knows best. Then, when the whole thing predictably implodes, we are told that the uptick in unemployment, the drop in home sales, etc., was "unexpected." Unexpected by whom? Thomas Sowell, Walter Williams, and many other great minds certainly expect it and predict it. But the eggheads at the NYT and the Obama administration are perpetually caught with there intellectual pants down on this stuff. This isn't the audacity of hope. It's the audacity of arrogance and absurdity. Back to my coffee now.

Dave Carter

Folks, these are wonderful comments that are best not read in a public restaurant. People are staring at me wondering why I'm laughing out loud like this while sitting by myself. The guys in white coats will be here shortly. It was nice knowing you all.

x

Most Popular Services

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Join Ricochet today!