Bio

Emily Esfahani Smith is the editor of the pop-culture blog Acculturated, associate editor of The New Criterion, and managing editor of the Hoover Institution journal Defining Ideas. A 2009 Dartmouth College graduate, she was editor of The Dartmouth Review. Her writings have also appeared in the Wall Street Journal, The New Criterion, The Daily Beast, Weekly Standard, American Spectator Online, and National Review Online. Emily contributed a chapter titled “Performance Art: The Faux Creativity of Lady Gaga” to Acculturated, a book published in 2011 by Templeton Press. Follow Emily on twitter, @EmEsfahaniSmith. 


People Emily Esfahani Smith is Following (8)



People Following Emily Esfahani Smith (49)

Display starting at 49 of 49 followers


Conversations Emily Esfahani Smith is Following (274)

Display starting at 274 of 274 followed conversations


Conversations Emily Esfahani Smith has Started (334)

Display starting at 334 of 334 user conversations

Emily Esfahani Smith's Profile

Emily Esfahani Smith
Name:
Emily Esfahani Smith
Hometown:
New York City
Joined:
May 24, 2010

Recent Comments

Emily Esfahani Smith

As you all know, I'm a fan of the trailer. And the way I see it, ya'll should just be grateful that it's not Gatsby: The Musical. Just sayin' ; )

Emily Esfahani Smith

Mollie Hemingway, Ed.: I love Brain Pickings. I don't love the odd anti-religious bias on display at times, but the pickings have been very helpful to me. Many of my children's favorite books -- and mine -- were found via BP.

The love of design is synthesized through the whole site. It's the only email newsletter I enjoy looking at. And it helps me trust them when they say "this is a beautifully designed book." · 5 minutes ago

Yes, the anti-religion bias is too bad. It's the same story, kind of, at TED: I love most of the talks, but the many of the speakers are a little politically naive. 

Emily Esfahani Smith

It's so horrifying to think about what these dissidents have to endure. There's a piece today in Hoover's Defining Ideas about another Chinese dissident who has experienced the brutality of the Chinese regime, and the details are awful:

This dissident writer, Yu Jie, likes to refer to himself as a nerd who stutters. In mid-January, he showed up in the United States on self-imposed exile. He revealed that the Chinese government had tortured him for his pro-democracy writings and activities. Additionally, the authorities had subjected him to detention and house arrest, tapped his phones, intercepted his emails, confiscated his computer and research, banned the publication of his work in China, and threatened to bury him alive. That China mistreats its citizens and abuses its political dissidents is nothing new, but Yu’s story magnifies China’s incongruities, and his departure offers a most potent reminder of the country’s tragedies.

Emily Esfahani Smith
Stuart Creque: I am confused. The parts of the woman's letter you quoted don't mention love at all, only sex. The advice columnist is also confused: she seems to think that the sole purpose of marriage is to have sex.Sexual obsession is not love. It also is an insufficient foundation for a marriage (outside of those instant marriages that last only long enough to legitimize a sexual relationship).The letter writer probably is acting out her anxiety about entering into marriage and pledging fidelity to one man. Her sex partner represents a lifeline to her youthful freedom and she is terrified of letting it go. She isn't drawn to the sex partner by love: she's afraid of the love she has with her fiancé and the power it will have over her. · 7 minutes ago

That's a great point. To the advice columnist, love = sex, which is a pretty superficial, and not to say wrong (!), conception of love.

Emily Esfahani Smith

Paul A. Rahe: Something seems to me to be missing in the various discussions quoted -- the need for a common project to unite the two lovers. Passion in this regard is no more sufficient than is a ham sandwich. One can always find it somewhere else, and novelty has its charms.

The common project is another matter. Precisely because it is common, it unites two particular people, and it keeps them united. The real problem with Hollywood's representation of love is its silence with regard to children. · 5 minutes ago

Yes -- or where children are involved, it's outside of the marriage context (in films like Knocked Up and Friends With Kids). 

Emily Esfahani Smith

So sad I can't come! I just received Elizabeth Kantor's book in the mail and look forward to jumping into it. 

Have fun everyone. Take pictures!

Emily Esfahani Smith
Western Chauvinist: At 30, I was 8 years into my marriage. I say this not as a criticism of the list (although I think there are legitimate ones to make). I'm just observing how much society has changed in a relatively brief period of time. For many of us in the previous generation, marriage and family came first, with worries about acquiring a new piece of furniture and developing a resume somewhere down the list. · 28 minutes ago

I think that most women today--outside of the feminist fringe--would also admit that marriage and family come first. But they would say that building a career (i.e. being on stable financial footing) is a prerequisite to having a family. I wouldn't disagree. 

Emily Esfahani Smith

It's an interesting point you bring up, Maura, and one that appears in at least three culture-defining shows: Friends, Sex and the City, and now Girls. These shows are all about friendship; our friends will always be there for us--support us, as you say--no matter what. 

I think there are two ideas in these shows that really appeal to our culture. First, the idea of friendship. Friends have displaced family as the main source of moral and social support, especially now that we all leave home after high school for good. The second idea is nonjudgmental support, and I think that's really a relic of our morally relativistic culture. As a friend, one of your duties is to support your friends without judging their choices because there is no right or wrong, there is only how they feel. If they feel bad, you should comfort them. If they feel good, then great. 

This raises a question: Is a good friend one who blindly supports their friends, or is a good friend someone who tells their friends the truth, no matter how uncomfortable it may be? In Girls, we see the Marnie character do both.

Edited on Apr 24 at 12:23pm
Emily Esfahani Smith
Diane Ellis, Ed.: On the other end of the spectrum, you have the kids in Modern Family who seem happy and well adjusted.  Claire and Phil Dunphy's kids have a smart and active stay-at-home mom who does things like run for local office and a dad who works in real estate, but who obviously values his family over his career.   · 23 minutes ago

That's a good point. But like you say, those are parents who have decided to put family first (as opposed to the parents I mention, you put career first). 

Emily Esfahani Smith
EJHill: Oh, come on,  Misthiocracy, let's not take the fun out of cleavage! · 12 minutes ago

I think after the word SEX, the cleavage is the second most noticeable thing on the covers (maybe the first, to some). 

Emily Esfahani Smith

Mark Belling Fan

tabula rasa: Maybe they should do a "Non-Sex Issue."  

I had the same thought as soon as I saw the Lady Gaga cover in Emily's original post.

"Slightly more feminine than Ziggy Stardust" is not a good look for anyone. · 4 hours ago

Well put!

Emily Esfahani Smith

@Duane, I love TGI Friday's too. The atmosphere, the food, it's just all so fun.

@Paul, I hear you re Olive Garden.  There's nothing quite like those buttery breadsticks. What are the main eateries in Hillsdale? 

Emily Esfahani Smith

Mollie Hemingway, Ed.: I loved what Hagerty's editor said about the review -- that longtime readers of hers would understand that her commentary more on the decor than the food meant it was not the most favorable review.

Good old midwestern nice ... · 5 minutes ago

I know, I loved this part too!

Emily Esfahani Smith

I also find it interesting that she always makes these self-deprecating jokes about how she hates kids, doesn't ever want to have kids, would be a terrible mother, etc. But putting it all together, you're right, Mollie--it's all very angry. 

Emily Esfahani Smith

Leslie Watkins: My father was one of those people who claimed that what Clinton did wasn't sex. (The obsession with certain body parts boggles the mind.) So, I said, okay, dad. Say some young woman serviced you this way. Would you tell mom? After all, it isn't sex, is it? · 3 minutes ago

Humza Ahmad: I was a teenager during the sex scandal, and there is no doubt that adults willing to give the President a pass on something like that meant that we were allowed to do it too. I do blame much of today's teenage promiscuity on the media's unabashed attitude towards sex, the Clinton scandal being but one of many examples. · 10 minutes ago

Great point. That must have been quite the conversation!

Emily Esfahani Smith
Haakon Dahl: This does seem like salacious click-farming, comment-ranching.   1 minute ago

Uh huh, but you couldn't hold yourself back from commenting ; )

Welcome Visitor

Already a Member?
Please Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Join Ricochet today!

Already a Member? Sign In