Bio

Creative writer, political reader, living in NYC. Doing my best to defy the stereotype that all homosexuals are all left-wing whackjobs. I may be a homosexual. And a whackjob. But I haven't been left-wing since I was in high school in the 90's. We all make a mistakes at that age, right?


People Jonathan Matthew Gilbert is Following (14)



People Following Jonathan Matthew Gilbert (5)



Conversations Jonathan Matthew Gilbert is Following

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert is not following any conversations.


Conversations Jonathan Matthew Gilbert has Started

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert has not started any conversations.

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert's Profile

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert
Name:
Jonathan Matthew Gilbert
Hometown:
Knoxville, TN
Joined:
Jul 1, 2010

Recent Comments

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

Here's the thing. I don't really believe Romney's unfavorables are solid, I think he has time to persuade. Newt is pretty known; I'd wager that few of us doubt Marianne's comments, even if we believe he's not the same man now. Newt's unfavorables don't seem likely to move. If we must have a nominee with 56% disapproval...why can't it be Palin? I have no faith that she can win either but I like her a heck of a lot more than Newt.

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

Another worry we don't have with Newt: how to actually fix any of the problems this country faces. I feel like I'm watching a major political party commit suicide right before my eyes. 

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

I've seen it--twice, now, actually--and I don't necessarily agree with this review but I personally felt it left more than a bit to be desired. Meryl Streep's performance is breath-taking, but Thatcher's actual convictions and beliefs are not explored much and a lot of huge moments are rushed through or completely ignored. Thatcher is painted with a great deal of respect and very little history is fudged--even Thatcher's children will tell you she was not especially present in their childhood, and her attention to Dennis is a huge part of the film's core, she's definitely not presented as an absent wife though she is presented as someone who chose to pursue her personal ambitions much more than many other women of her time. Which is true. It's definitely worth seeing to form your own opinion, Meryl's performance alone makes it so, and Jim Broadbent and Olivia Colman are excellent as Dennis and Carol. 

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

I've never understood the compulsion to judge a work of art--be it theatre, film, television, sculpture, etc--without actually examining it. Goodness knows, no one on here would want me to judge their personal positions, religions or accomplishments without thoroughly considering them, right? I was initially very skeptical about The Book of Mormon because it seemed to me that it could only be coming from a place of mockery and there's an awful lot of Mormons in musical theatre, so...that didn't seem like a smart or necessary thing to do. Then I saw it. With my Mormon collaborator, as it so happens (we're both trained in musical theatre writing and are currently working on a piece about Margaret Thatcher, so while we're biased in favor of musicals...we're both pretty solidly-credentialed conservatives).

We both loved it. It's full of heart, and it will last. The only surviving creator of West Side Story agrees. Perhaps you should consider checking it out before you decide to write it off.

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

God, I wish that happened on the New York City subway system. My morning commute would be a lot more peaceful. 

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

No, this...this does not inspire confidence. 

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

I'm not convinced she's finished yet and she's pretty likely to get my vote in the primary if she runs--though a lot of that has to do with New York being late enough in the game that it really won't matter much who I vote for in the primary. At this point in 2007, McCain's candidacy was a joke and Obama was 30 points below Clinton, so...anything could happen. The woman definitely hits her mark an awful lot, that's for sure.

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

Michelle Bachmann became a Republican after she misinterpreted a Gore Vidal book; absolutely no one in the middle is going to take her seriously, so she's more than welcome to run and keep things entertaining but if she should stumble into the nomination, we're stuck with the President. It'd be nice if the dark horse actually turned out to be a viable contender who could persuade people in the middle or even disaffected Obama supporters to vote for them. While I wish we lived in a world in which Palin could actually win, the person I'm keeping an eye on at the moment is Huntsman.

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

"See what happens when you let gays into the military?" (Not mine, but one of the ones I enjoyed most on Twitter last night.)

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

I think it's safe to assume most of us on here are in that 46% or so who will NEVER vote for him, no matter what...but I do think this is going to be influential to some of the folks in the middle, and it may actually energize a few of his disaffected supporters. For a while, at least. I think in the minds of a lot of journalists, this HAS changed his presidency forever and ensured re-election but those aren't objective individuals when it comes to this man. We know that. We'll see how much this is still a game-changer in 18 months. If gas is over $6/gallon...it won't matter in the least.

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

Who would even WANT 72 virgins? SO MUCH WORK involved in that...

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

Several times I have stopped conversations dead by repeating Claire's question about whether or not gays who attack Israel have every given the slightest bit of thought to what life would be like for gays in Palestine. I'm ashamed of my brethren in London. And will take them to task for this.

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

The President just blinked in a staring contest with Donald Trump, giving the Don a lot more credibility than he had yesterday. I don't see how that was smart for the White House, though I don't know why I'm surprised any longer when they do things that aren't very smart...

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

I'm keeping an eye on Gillibrand and Maria Cantwell, but I haven't seen strong indication yet that either of them wants it. If Obama is re-elected, 2016 should be fairly easy for the GOP regardless of which Democrat manages to emerge and almost regardless of which of our fine candidates we choose (but I'll be pulling for Christie-Rubio personally...)

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert

Tommy De Seno

Jonathan Matthew Gilbert: Always so nice to be lumped in with the polygamists, but I agree with the basic thesis here. I'm not pro-abortion but I do believe that it's a private medical decision--and one that involves the termination of a life, but I don't believe all human life to be inviolate (I'm strongly in favor of the death penalty, too). I'm more of a Barry Goldwater conservative: I think there are very strict limits to the places in a person's private life that the government can go. Out of the bedroom, out of the boardroom. · Apr 20 at 1:47pm

My decision to kill you would be equally as private. · Apr 20 at 1:50pm

Honestly? This is your response? How mature. 

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Join Ricochet today!

Already a Member? Sign In