Bio
Mild-mannered college professor by day, astrophysicist by night. Methodist, Southerner, East Tennessee hillbilly.
I'm a traditional Southern conservative with a strong libertarian streak. A sunny optimist, practically a Pollyanna, who is nevertheless clinging to his guns and religion because human nature is unchanging.


Re: Why I want illegal immigration stopped at the border, and the rest of us left alone
...cont'd...
But no, this current annoyance doesn't mean the law is wrong. I've been bugged by this law for many years. It just seems wrong that the Federal government should have a say-so in whether or not I'm allowed to work. It's not an explicit power in the Constitution, and it seems to exceed the "necessary and proper" clause. (Maybe we could argue necessity, but proper?)
It's not a matter of their prosecuting me, if I were an illegal immigrant or someone on a non-working visa. That I would agree with. What makes me cringe is that they've created a system of prior restraint. You're presumably not allowed to work, unless you can prove you are.
I understand this makes it easier to catch illegal aliens (etc.) than if they had to wait until illegal work is done and then investigate and prosecute it. Prior restraint is probably always easier than the alternatives. And I'm against amnesties and want to keep illegal immigration...illegal.
Maybe this is the most practical system we can have.
But I hate it.