This section of Matthew Gilley's profile is hidden.


People Following Matthew Gilley

This section of Matthew Gilley's profile is hidden.


Conversations Matthew Gilley is Following

This section of Matthew Gilley's profile is hidden.


Conversations Matthew Gilley has Started (31)

Display starting at 31 of 31 user conversations

Matthew Gilley's Profile

Matthew Gilley
Name:
Matthew Gilley
Hometown:
Spartanburg, South Carolina
Joined:
May 31, 2010

Recent Comments

Matthew Gilley

If you don't want to succumb to the nagging feeling, then I recommend you not look at Glenn Thrush's Twitter feed.

Matthew Gilley

Michael Scott lives.

Troy Senik, Ed

"Don't worry, I'll be there with a fire hose!" 

"That's what she said."

Edited on May 21, 2013 at 1:30am
Matthew Gilley

QBF- excellent observation about administrative law. In a sense, it's funny to see Justice Thomas in the majority here. Justice Scalia took a similar view in Smith v. City of Jackson and deferred to the EEOC on the question of whether the Age Discrimination in Employment Act allowed disparate impact causes of action (I wrote an article accusing him of "punting"). Justice Thomas, himself a former Commissioner of the EEOC, declined to defer. I guess familiarity breeds contempt.

Matthew Gilley

"Umm, yeah, hi there, G. Gordon ... this is Bebe from Miami. Big fan - long time listener, first time caller. Say, I heard something about a burglary at the Watergate a few days ago. You happen to hear about that? Know what may've been going down? Thanks, and I'll just hang up and listen to what y'all have to say."

Matthew Gilley

Crow's Nest: ....

However, it is also important that, as part of that duty, they uphold their dignity and avoid the appearance of impropriety and unnecessary petty partisan politics. We're not offended that DOJ targeted one group or another that we are supportive of--we're concerned that DOJ has systematically, in different areas, failed in its Constitutional duties. The facts of the case must be outed. 

Issa et al. should approach their questioning by keeping all of the above in mind, and they should approach it by endeavoring to keep their cool. Make Holder uncomfortable--make him lash out; make him lie to cover himself. 

A better course than the way Issa adopted in the clip above would have been to use the "perhaps he didn't want us to see the contents" in a moment with the press later. 

You're correct, but the problem is that your advice is out of place.  Is that how I would handle a witness under oath at a trial, hearing, or deposition?  You bet, 100%.  The difference is that as much as we would prefer otherwise, politics is a contact sport.  Issa threw an elbow that needed to be thrown.

Matthew Gilley

Big Green

Matthew Gilley: Tom, most people sitting in Holder's seat didn't preside over a department that seized reporters' phone records under dubious circumstances. Most people sitting in Holder's seat didn't duck responsibility and evade questions for those shenanigans by playing stupid. Most people sitting in Holder's position didn't spike a slam dunk voting rights prosecution for no good reason. ...

Let's just assume all that is true....

That's an interesting lead - do you doubt any of that was true?

Big Green

Chris Campion: Is calling Holder's conduct at DoJ "unacceptable" acceptable in a hearing on the unacceptability of his tenure at the DoJ?

....

I think this is mostly beside the point.  Even if his behavior is unacceptable, does it further Issa's cause or progress on the issue at hand to make serious accusations and then attempt to prevent the witness from responding?  I don't think so. 

Why should Congressman Issa should care when his witness has been held in contempt of Congress and has repeatedly stonewalled Issa's progress and cause?  Any progress will come from other witnesses; Holder is a waste of time at this point.

Matthew Gilley
Tom Kirkwold: The Republicans may have an opportunity here.  They need to step it up.  That's all I'm saying.  I'm not defending Holder.  Anybody can badger the witness but then it will just be a cheap sideshow with nothing to show for it in the end. ยท 9 minutes ago

Step it up, eh?  I think you can count on that happening.

Here's the thing, though:  a witness has two jobs - (1) answer questions and (2) tell the truth.  Eric Holder has spent five years doing precious little of either.  If Republicans are going to "step it up" and get to the truth, they're going to have to go around Holder and the rest of the cabinet directly to front line people (like the Benghazi whistleblowers).  Yes, Republicans have an opportunity here, and extending courtesy to Eric Holder has nothing to do with seizing it. 

Matthew Gilley

We all grow up some day.

Matthew Gilley

Tom, most people sitting in Holder's seat didn't preside over a department that seized reporters' phone records under dubious circumstances. Most people sitting in Holder's seat didn't duck responsibility and evade questions for those shenanigans by playing stupid. Most people sitting in Holder's position didn't spike a slam dunk voting rights prosecution for no good reason. Maybe, just maybe, Holder needs to look in the mirror if he wants to know why he's not getting his boots licked as tenderly as he would prefer.

Matthew Gilley

Nothing beats this scene from "Frasier," which skewers wine tasting's pretentious quackery: http://youtu.be/WJagAyCGZbg.

Matthew Gilley

I wonder how Chick-Fil-A and its franchises have fared?"In seemingly unrelated news, the New England Patriots took the unusual step of canceling mini camp workouts so that several players could attend to urgent personal business. No further details were available about the nature of the players' need for time off, although Tom Brady was spotted leaving team facilities with several banker boxes of bank statements while Coach Bill Belichick followed behind clutching fistfuls of wadded Academy Sports receipts for sleeveless gray hoodies...."

Matthew Gilley

I have a sudden strange urge to create a font that resembles jumbled letters cut from magazines and newspapers.

Matthew Gilley

From "Dewey Defeats Truman" to "Sanford Defeats Clown's Sister." The South Carolina Dems are stepping up their game, though - she's a marked improvement over Alvin Greene. We better be careful. You never know whether Michael Moore has a brother jonesing to move to Hilton Head or Myrtle Beach.

Matthew Gilley

"When Republicans rebel."

Matthew Gilley

Wow, for an event like this, make sure you wear your best, most crisply ironed shirt. Oh, wait....

Matthew Gilley

Since he's too circumspect to name names, here are my guesses: McCain, Kirk, Graham, Hatch, Grassley. Others?

Welcome Visitor!
Join  or  Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Ricochet: The Right People, The Right Tone, The Right Place.  Join today!

Already a Member? Sign In