Bio

Midwestern owner of a small business.  Gun collector.  Political junkie.  History buff.


This section of skipsul's profile is hidden.


People Following skipsul

This section of skipsul's profile is hidden.


Conversations skipsul is Following

This section of skipsul's profile is hidden.


Conversations skipsul has Started (98)

Display starting at 68 of 98 user conversations

skipsul's Profile

skipsul
Name:
skipsul
Joined:
Mar 21, 2011

Recent Comments

skipsul
ctlaw: BTW, In what world does a"cold fusion" device absorb heat? · 3 hours ago

In the world where Kronos is only 5 minutes from Earth, the Enterprise takes 4+ years to build while a dreadnaught takes only 1 year, and where nobody seems to mind the giant starship engaged in a crash urban renewal project in SF.

skipsul

You forgot the part where, as the police chief is up for re-election, he is going around citing how much crime has gone down on his watch, and how safe places like Elm street are.  This horrible "incident" was clearly a spontaneous accident of multiple people unsafely cleaning loaded firearms while watching Bill O'Reilly.  Spontaneous TV rage.

skipsul

Never ever liked DS9, was a soap opera set in a war zone.  Voyager was unwatchable and preachy.  Agreed that TNG probably went on at least 1 season too long, got stale.

On the new films I still go back to this:  if you are going to do a "reboot" can you at least take it seriously?  I don't need cheap homages to the old series tossed in everywhere (the uniforms at Star Fleet Command are clearly drawn from ST_TMP), nor do I need you to recycle old enemies like this is some comic book reboot.  In 10 years there will be another new "Star Trek" with another new Khan and another crew, just like every few years there's a new Peter Parker and a new Clark Kent.

The whole galaxy is your canvas, try something new besides improved effects.

And stop slamming the military all the time.

And Kronos is really only 5 minutes away from Earth by max warp?  Really?  Seriously?

skipsul

To turn this back to the original point:

1.  Post Office - I think we can all agree this needs to go private.

2.  Ambulance service - should be private, but also needs the stink of our current insurance racket removed so that a 12 block ride doesn't cost $16k.

3.  Garbage - easy call really as just about every business uses a private contractor already.

4.  Fire?  Hmm...  Tougher call.  Privatization necessary, but hard sell to public.  Much cronyism there.

And sending a fire truck, ambulance, rescue truck, and 3 cop cars for every damn fender bender?  Union rules and budget justification.  We triage in hospitals, we should triage accident scenes and squad calls too.

skipsul

@EstoniaKat - I like your idea of using BC as a different popsicle, would have been much better for the film.

skipsul

@Tom - can you tell I only got a "D" in Latin? 

Glad you fleshed out Crassus, I didn't have the time.  Interesting life there, very interesting death too.

skipsul

Pilli

skipsul: [...]  Took a call to congressman to get the heat off, but then the congressman of course wanted some grease in the form of PR and "contributions to his campaign."

Nasty business all around. · 9 hours ago

Skip,  Who was the Congressman?  What party? · 17 hours ago

Ain't sayin' because it was 20 years ago now.

skipsul

Yudansha:CONT.

Khan - Call me crazy but liked BC's version of Khan better than RM's.  It was mentioned earlier that he played not one iota of swagger -- he was clearly ruthless though.  As for his race? Come on --  eugenics-- remember?  If you can make someone as strong as three men, how hard can it be to add blue eyes?  His basso-profundo rumble is marvelous. And who's got a cooler name thanBenedict Cumberbatch?  I just love that name!

I have to ask, though, if BC is so good why not make him his own villain?

Khan was originally his own man, in this he struck me as a weenie and not really clever.  Physically tough, sure, but not so smart.  I'm sorry, I don't believe a villain to be smart just because people in the move tell me he is.  

BC was a pawn, not a Khan.

skipsul

Amy Schley

Yes, if the story was better written it would have incorporated a backstory for how Khan is both a Latin man with an Indian name and a taste for quoting Herman Melville and a pasty Brit who kicks butt in fistfights.  But it didn't.  This theory is consistent with all the information provided in the movie and helps give the movie increased depth and emotion.  So that's what I'll believe to help make the story better than what was presented. 

I don't try inventing backstories to try to resolve plot discrepancies, I try to avoid plot discrepancies in the first place.  I also take stories as they're presented.  If a story has holes, it's not my job to fill them, it's the writer's job.  I'm not there to do the work the writer was too lazy or incompetent or careless to do.

Which brings up the point, why Khan at all?  If they named him anything else it would have improved the film, otherwise it's a silly sop to sentimentalism.

Khan was a true villain originally, in this he's just a tough tool.  They made him sympathetic.

skipsul

Amy Schley

skipsul

Sabrdance: I'm still mulling, but my one sentence review was "if you wanted to see what Wrath of Khan would look like if it was badly written and ham-handedly produced, then this is the movie for you."

I'm stealing this line.

Yup, Spock doing the "KHAAAANNN" thing was gratuitous and hammy.

You got 1 thing wrong, Khanberpatch does NOT have Montalban's chest: · 0 minutes ago

Khanberbatch doesn't need to ... he has the voice of a purring jaguar making love to a cello.

I could listen to that man read the tax code and be completely enthralled. · 11 minutes ago

Your bias betrays you.

skipsul

Amy Schley

As for Khanberbatch, I came across a fascinating fan theory.  In Space Seed, there are 84 Augments. ID has 72 frozen Augments plus Khanberbatch.  The movie establishes that thawing these people out is very difficult. So what if those missing eleven Augments were killed as failed attempts to thaw them out, and the "real" Khan was one of them? They awake Cumberbatch's character who was one of Khan's lieutenants  and he finds out Khan is dead.  "Khan" is a title more than a name, so Cumberbatch takes on the title of Khan (note that only Spock Prime adds the "Noonien Singh") and the responsibility for taking care of the remaining Augments.

This is going to sound mean, but...

I'm sorry, but this explanation reads like a Jay Carney press conference explaining why Benghazi was really perpetrated by the rogue IRS, who were suffering under the Sequester.

skipsul
Sabrdance: I'm still mulling, but my one sentence review was "if you wanted to see what Wrath of Khan would look like if it was badly written and ham-handedly produced, then this is the movie for you."

I'm stealing this line.

Yup, Spock doing the "KHAAAANNN" thing was gratuitous and hammy.

You got 1 thing wrong, Khanberpatch does NOT have Montalban's chest:

th

THAT is the chest of Khan.

Edited on May 20, 2013 at 10:45pm
skipsul

Mike Hinton: @skipsul

I too live in Franklin County, cheers!

Yikes, that's quite the story. So, you feel these kinds of entities would still pop up spontaneously in a privatized world and require a larger legitimate authority to smash them? · 18 minutes ago

BTW, cheers back at you!  Always glad to meet another local.  Still trying to actually meet EJ Hill as he's a local too.

skipsul

Mike Hinton: @skipsul

I too live in Franklin County, cheers!

Yikes, that's quite the story. So, you feel these kinds of entities would still pop up spontaneously in a privatized world and require a larger legitimate authority to smash them? · 0 minutes ago

I've known too many petty tyrants, you have to have something to use against them, short of selling your house and moving.  

Take homeowners' associations: pure unadulterated evil.

I became president of mine just to make sure it never did a damn thing after (5 years later my neighbors ask, what association?).

My wife is a lawyer and has had to represent friends who have been victimized by HOAs.  The HOA deed restrictions are a sort of "land slavery", and unless forbidden by the state are pretty well impossible to contest.  

Also, the people who run the HOAs or local governments tend to be those most interested in minding others' business (and landscaping).  Unless caught in a major scandal these become lifetime sinecures as local reporting is basically useless. 

Hard to fight the power unless you can bring in bigger guns.

skipsul

Where do I begin?  Didn't hate it, but...

For crying out loud, if you're going to do a fance "reboot" at least show some originalism!  Egad but it was silly.

I could nitpick the time and space contractions, but what annoyed me most was this:

Why does Hollywood always have an admiral or general gone rogue and trying to start a war as the "real" villian?  This is such unbelievable BS, not to mention done absolutely to death.

Ugh.

Insulting.

skipsul

The King Prawn

skipsul: The real mistake here is in Congress delegating away its powers.  It is on Congress to set and enforce limits.  The failure to do so is the heart of our troubles. · 14 minutes ago

This is my thinking on it. The battle should be between the elected branches with the judicial only refereeing the fight. Perhaps a chain linked octogon instead of a committee room is a more appropriate venue. · 0 minutes ago

Thunderdome?

Welcome Visitor!
Join  or  Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Ricochet: The Right People, The Right Tone, The Right Place.  Join today!

Already a Member? Sign In